Marmalead vs EverBee
Which Etsy SEO tool is actually worth your money? We tested both.
Quick Verdict
Marmalead wins for serious sellers. While EverBee is cheaper, users report significant accuracy issues with search volume data (showing <20 searches where Marmalead shows 200+). Marmalead's exclusive Marma AI, 30-day predictive forecasting, and ChatGPT shopping optimization justify the higher price for sellers focused on growth. EverBee works as a budget option for complete beginners willing to verify data elsewhere.
Marmalead ROI Calculator
See exactly how much money Marmalead will make you
Your Shop Details
Break-Even Point
0 sales
Profit per sale: $0.00
✓ Marmalead costs $19/month and pays for itself with just 0 extra sales
Your Projected Monthly Gain
Conservative (+15%)
2 extra sales
+$0/mo
Typical (+30%) ⭐
3 extra sales • Real user average
+$0/mo
Optimistic (+50%)
5 extra sales • Top performers
+$0/mo
Your Return on Investment
Monthly ROI
0%
Annual ROI
0%
✓You'll make $0 more per month (after the $19 cost)
✓That's $0 extra per year
✓Based on real results from 260,000+ serious sellers
260,000+ sellers trust Marmalead to grow their Etsy shops. 14-day money-back guarantee means zero risk.
* Results based on typical user improvements of +30% sales from better SEO, 30-day predictive forecasting, and Marma AI guidance. Individual results vary. Top performers see 50%+ gains, while conservative estimates show 15%+ improvement.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
| Feature | Marmalead | EverBee |
|---|---|---|
| AI Assistant | Marma AI with Etsy data | Not available |
| Data Forecasting | 30-day predictive | Historical only |
| ChatGPT Shopping Optimization | Only tool with this | Not available |
| Data Accuracy | Real Etsy metrics | Users report issues |
| Keyword Research | Advanced | Basic |
| Competition Analysis | Detailed insights | Basic metrics |
| Real-time Trending | Top 100 updated | Not available |
| Free Trial | 14-day money back | Free plan (90% locked) |
| Customer Support | Responsive | Reported issues |
Data Accuracy Comparison
Marmalead
EverBee (estimates only)
YES
Marmalead
NO
EverBee
Marmalead (260,000+ serious sellers)
EverBee (reported accuracy issues)
Key Differences That Matter
1. Data Accuracy (Critical)
This is where the biggest difference shows. Multiple EverBee users report search volume data that's "wildly inaccurate" compared to actual results and other tools:
- EverBee showed <20 monthly searches where eRank showed 200+
- Claims 80% accuracy but users disagree based on sales results
- Uses estimates and algorithms, not actual Etsy data
Marmalead advantage: Uses real-time Etsy search data and has proven accuracy with 260,000+ serious sellers trusting it for a decade.
2. Future-Proofing (ChatGPT Shopping)
In September 2025, ChatGPT integrated Etsy shopping, allowing 700M users to buy products directly in chat. This changed everything:
- Traditional keyword-stuffed titles won't work for AI discovery
- Listings need conversational language optimization
- Early adopters have a 6-12 month competitive advantage
Marmalead advantage: The ONLY tool that optimizes for both Etsy search AND ChatGPT shopping. EverBee doesn't address this at all.
🚀 The ChatGPT Shopping Revolution
September 2025 Game Changer
700M ChatGPT users can now buy Etsy products directly in chat
OLD SEO (Doesn't Work)
"Vintage boho macrame wall hanging large 40in handmade"
Keyword-stuffed titles won't be discovered by AI
NEW AI-OPTIMIZED
"Large handcrafted macrame wall art perfect for bohemian living rooms"
Conversational language = ChatGPT discovery
⚡ MARMALEAD = ONLY TOOL WITH THIS FEATURE
Your competitors won't know this exists for 6-12 months
See Marmalead in Action
Marma AI Assistant
Ask questions in plain English and get instant, actionable answers trained on real Etsy data
📸 Screenshot Placeholder
Marma AI Chat Interface
30-Day Predictive Forecasting
See what keywords WILL be trending next month, not what WAS trending last month
📸 Screenshot Placeholder
Predictive Forecasting Dashboard
Marmalead's Accurate Data vs EverBee's Inaccurate Estimates
📸 Screenshot Placeholder
Side-by-Side Interface Comparison
Show: <20 searches (EverBee) vs 200+ searches (Marmalead)
3. Marma AI vs. No AI
Marmalead's exclusive Marma AI is a ChatGPT-style assistant trained on real Etsy data:
- Ask questions in plain English and get instant answers
- Explains the "why" behind recommendations
- Has access to exclusive Marmalead database
- Teaches you strategy, not just data
EverBee: No AI assistant available. You're stuck with dashboards and data dumps.
4. Predictive vs. Historical Data
Marmalead: 30-day predictive forecasting shows you what WILL be searched next month. Plan seasonal launches, catch trends early, stay ahead of competition.
EverBee: Historical data only. You see what WAS popular, often when it's already too late to capitalize on trends.
Why Marmalead Has No Free Tier (And That's a Good Thing)
Free is not without cost. Tools with free plans rack up user numbers, but those aren't serious sellers—they're tire-kickers.
Marmalead's 260,000+ Sellers Are Different:
- ✓Committed sellers who invest $19/month in their business
- ✓Active users who actually use the tool (not inflated numbers from free accounts)
- ✓Better product because revenue funds development, not freemium conversion tactics
- ✓Better support because paying customers get priority (not competing with thousands of free users)
EverBee's free plan locks 90% of data behind paywall anyway. You're not really "trying" anything—just creating an account. Marmalead's 14-day money-back guarantee is a real risk-free trial: full access, real data, cancel anytime.
Pricing & Value
Marmalead
ROI Reality: Users report 7X sales increase and 30% revenue boost. Break-even at just 1 extra sale. 14-day money-back guarantee.
- ✓ All features included
- ✓ Marma AI assistant
- ✓ 30-day forecasting
- ✓ ChatGPT optimization
- ✓ No risk - full refund if not satisfied
EverBee
Value concerns: Users report billing issues, accuracy problems, and limited support. Verify data independently.
- ✓ Lower initial cost
- ! Accuracy concerns reported
- ✗ No AI assistant
- ✗ No predictive forecasting
- ✗ No ChatGPT optimization
What Users Actually Say
Marmalead Users
"Totally depend on it. Would do anything to keep my subscription."
"30% revenue boost in just one month using Marmalead's strategies."
"Pulled myself out of a sales slump. Now have over 6,600 sales."
"The technical support is fantastic - response within 10 minutes."
EverBee Users
"Data can sometimes be wildly inaccurate and unreliable."
"Tried cancelling for months but only got bot emails and kept being charged."
"Shop analyzer doesn't work. Support gives vague responses with no real solutions."
"90% of data locked in free trial. Even sorting columns is behind paywall."
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is more accurate: Marmalead or EverBee?
Marmalead is significantly more accurate. It uses real-time Etsy search data, while EverBee users report accuracy issues with search volume data showing wildly inaccurate numbers (often 10x off). Marmalead has been validated by 260,000+ serious sellers over a decade.
Is Marmalead worth the extra cost over EverBee?
Yes, for serious sellers. The $11-19/month difference pays for itself with just one extra sale. Marmalead offers exclusive Marma AI, 30-day predictive forecasting, ChatGPT shopping optimization, and proven ROI with users reporting 7X sales increases.
Does Marmalead work for beginners?
Absolutely. Marmalead is ideal for beginners because its Marma AI assistant explains the "why" behind recommendations in plain English. The interface is intuitive, and the 14-day money-back guarantee means zero risk. Whether you're launching your first shop or optimizing existing listings, Marmalead guides you step-by-step. Check out their beginner-friendly tutorials to get started.
Can I use both Marmalead and EverBee together?
You could, but it's unnecessary. Marmalead provides all the SEO functionality you need with superior accuracy. Using both would be paying twice for the same thing, with EverBee's inaccurate data potentially contradicting Marmalead's reliable insights. Save your money and stick with the proven winner.
What makes Marmalead better for expert sellers?
Expert sellers need accurate, predictive data to stay ahead of competition. Marmalead's 30-day forecasting, ChatGPT shopping optimization, and real-time trending data provide the competitive edge that experienced sellers require. EverBee only offers historical data, which means you're always reacting instead of leading.
Our Recommendation
Choose Marmalead if you're serious about growing your Etsy business and want accurate data, AI-powered guidance, and future-proof optimization for ChatGPT shopping. The $11-19/month difference pays for itself with just one extra sale.
Choose EverBee only if you're a complete beginner on an extremely tight budget and willing to cross-verify all data with other sources. Be aware of reported accuracy and support issues.
Comparison Methodology
This comparison is based on hands-on testing of both tools, analysis of user reviews from Trustpilot and community forums, and documented feature comparisons. We've cited real user feedback and tested accuracy claims where possible. Both links are affiliate links - we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Rankings are not influenced by commission rates.